GitM avatarGeorge In The Meta

Guide

Shaman or Paladin in WoW Forever? I switched, then went back

Short answer: if you're anything like me, play the paladin. I launched WoW Forever as a shaman to try something different, got one to level 22, and was back on a paladin by 16 November. A tank paladin is tanky and safe, and that's what saves me so much time when I'm levelling and not paying attention. Ret Paladin is also pretty good. It depends what your play style is.

Should you play Shaman or Paladin in WoW Forever?

Paladin, if you want to be tanky. I think you're likely to enjoy the paladin more if you're anything like me, but that's a tank paladin. Mine is still the wannabe, just hilariously tanky, doing a lot of reflected damage.

This time I'm a tank paladin without a shield, just a two-handed sword, and I'm still getting through it easily. With the two-hander I'm still tanky and I'm killing slightly faster. It's more parry and evasion than block, because we can't use any of the shield talents without a shield.

There's just something about Shaman that feels boring to me.

WoW Forever: a level 14 Human Paladin with a two-handed sword in Jangolode Mine, Westfall, on 722 health with zero deaths, the chat showing Defias Smugglers and Trappers dying
My paladin in Jangolode Mine on 18 November, six minutes after the Defias Smugglers. 722 health, deaths 0. Names blurred. Tap to enlarge.

Why did I play Shaman at launch instead of Paladin?

I played a shaman at launch because shaman was the thing I'd most recently played in the beta, and I wanted to try something different from the paladin. In the beta I'd mostly played Maple, an Undead Protection Paladin, and she got boring.

The paladin gets boring because it's just so tanky and safe, and it can sometimes be slow to kill things. So I launched with two shamans: Totem, an Orc Enhancement Shaman on Horde, and Short, a Dwarf Shaman on Alliance.

Why did I go back to Paladin?

I went back to paladin because levels 15 to 25 on a shaman were a slog. I kept asking my add-ons project about it, and it kept telling me 15 to 25 is tough, 15 to 25 is boring, 15 to 25 is a slog on a shaman. I was 22 and still thinking I've done 22 levels of eating shit, and at 25 it doesn't really pick up that much.

On 15 November I dropped Enhancement. Fighting one mob at a time was boring, and the fun had always been the big pulls on my tank paladin. I made a Dwarf Paladin that day and dropped her too, because I didn't want to do the Dwarf start again. The Human Paladin I play now started on 16 November.

How tanky is a Paladin in WoW Forever?

A paladin in WoW Forever is tanky enough to live through a pile-up that wasn't my fault. On 18 November in Westfall, someone died next to me and I ended up with all their bullshit following me: a pack of level 12 Defias Smugglers. My combat log counts seven different smugglers hitting me.

Blessing of Protection went up first, and eight seconds later I used Lay on Hands, at 248 health out of 722. Then I stunned the closest one with Hammer of Justice and got out. I didn't just perish because someone died near me.

To be fair to the shaman, I had Might of Stormwind on for that, which is 300 of those 722 health. What Might of Stormwind does is a big part of why the early levels feel so easy right now.

Is Paladin faster than Shaman for levelling?

My paladin got to level 8 faster than my shaman, but it isn't a fair race. These are active minutes from my combat logs, with idle gaps of over three minutes taken out.

To level 8Paladin (Human)Shaman (Dwarf)
Active timeAbout 91 minutesAbout 128 minutes
Kills with 2 or more mobs on me (levels 7 to 8)29 to 33%7 to 9%
Lowest health early onNever under 50% to level 6Died at level 6

The paladin had Might of Stormwind from level 2 onwards, and the shaman didn't. The shaman was grouped with a friend for levels 2 to 6, though only 19 of her 96 kills were shared. The only like-for-like level is level 1: 4 minutes on the paladin, 6.5 on the shaman.

What the numbers do show is the paladin taking on two or three mobs at once and not dying, which is how I like to play.

Do you always end up on the same class?

I always end up on the same class, or at least that's how it seems. When I was a kid I was a Tauren, so I was the cow. I think I was a mage later, around Lich King or Cataclysm, and everything after that I was a paladin. A lot of that was from watching Towelliee, the streamer who does the tanking.

Every time I've come back to WoW, I've ended up on a paladin. You kind of tend to know the one you're always going to be. This time I launched as a shaman, and 11 days later I was back on a paladin.

Related

WoW Forever clips from stream

Clips load from YouTube only when you press play.

As of 18 November 2026. My shaman, Short, is level 22; my paladin is level 14. Levelling times, kills and health are from my own combat logs, read by the add-ons project I run for my characters. The two characters didn't level in the same conditions, and that's covered below.